neijia_boxer wrote:i'd like to chime in since i have been experimenting with the material in the book, and i have boxing trainers on both sided of the spectrum. My old school style coach would agree with the light weights and helping improve your fighting skills since they are complementary to boxing and has a positive impact on my sparring. another coach of mine is a fitness and crossfit instructor and former pro boxer, and i'd say that his strength conditioning style it too much for me and detrimental (I'm age 40 now) to my body and makes me stiff for days, it is not helping my boxing, making me have stiff hips, (lower back pain) tight shoulders and arms. You dont get the relaxed snap of the jab from over worked muscles. Same with kicks in chinese martial arts, do a bunch of deadlifts and squats and your kicks are gonna slow down.
But again, I agree entirely with not doing heavy weights. What i'm looking for are the specific pro's given by this light weight training.
My point is not "why is heavy lifting bad", its "why is high rep light weights " good.
liokault wrote:But you are not talking functionality, you’re talking comparisons based on cosmetics.
I don't buy into heavy lifting improving punching power (hell, I don't even think push ups do much), but what do your light weights actually do? What attributes are you improving? What gains would you see if you did the training in your book, and why? What is there in the body addapting to lifting light weights that is beneficial to your fight game?
My big mental block on this (and why I don’t like push ups) is that I'm a great believer in training high reps is fundamentally just working your slow twitch muscle, which isn’t what you want to rely on for punching.
I was reading an interview by a boxing coach in an MMA gym a while back (wish I'd kelp it). His theory was that lots of young fighters come in, start early in their career with lots of KO's, they get bogged down in conventional high rep boxing training, lots of push ups etc etc and train themselves out of 'KO' power by developing a reliance on slow twitch muscle.
Read the book. I just finished it and it makes perfect sense as to how it would help a martial artist or boxer. The main reason would be neurological conditioning to be able to control and tense the appropriate muscles at the appropriate times. Basically increased proprioception and control over the muscular system while simultaneously increasing strength.
I've been doing it for about 10 days (skipped a few days with work) & think I have got the gist of it. I feel strong & think I am definitely going to stick with it. The mrs is digging the guns too
I got (am getting) a better feel for the muscles targeted in each exercise now i have been doing it a while, yesterday my deltoids just gave up! I have definitely noticed a change across my shoulder girdle and also finding it is helping a few nagging injuries that normally hurt if I train daily. I am working on doing the sun salutation in the morning & 'watch' in the evening & really enjoying it.
Definitely works, only complaint I have is the chest seems neglected
That said - Paranoid android if you want to hit the chest more I'd alternate sets of the "floor dips" with one set concentrating on the back, serratus anterior etc... then the next concentrating tension on the chest - just make sure that in doing so you don't allow the serratus to switch off and the shoulder blades to wing out or round the shoulders too much. Also once you get really good at controlling and contracting each muscle maximally you can use the first shoulder exercise to directly target the pectorals strongly on the return, inward, movement.
tsurugi wrote:
sounds like you're well on the right track - I noticed the shoulder girdle and arms responding first - and surprisingly quickly. You almost think "is is it just me or is this working already?" - good to have the Mrs confirm you aren't imagining it! Whichever muscle or muscle group responds best for you (deltoids maybe in your case) you will find that you can really induce the ideal effect in them. Once you've "felt it" there and you know what you're aiming for you can work towards inducing that exact same feeling in every area. Eventually you can get your spinal erectors or your obliques to give up in exactly the same way.
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan