D_Glenn wrote:
I'd like to just see your 5 elements or even just Pi and Beng Quan so I can see how it compares to the Xingyi I'd learned.
Also for another Xingyi standard it'd be good to see all the different variations of Dragon.
.
MikeK wrote:Simple Rule:
All memeber of this forum should post minimum of 20 mins video footage that in some small way represents their understanding and level of practice. So that we can all see where each other is comming from. Next people should support their post and opinions in threads with further video footage. This way we can minimize the confusion.
In an age when just about every mobile phone has a camera this is no big ask.
- If you are making some great claim about Santi or the like and you put up some clip of you doing Santi it will, by-in-large be quite obvious if you know what you are talking about.
- If you are an exponent of reality based martial art and train in the real deal, film it and show it, then we can see exactly what you mean, especially if your written posts come across unclearly to some of the "classically/traditionally" trained forum readers.
- If you have some great understanding of body mechnics and strucuture or some strong opinions on how power is expressed, film it so we can see and discuss what we have seen.
Pandrews1982 wrote:I say why doesn't Dan just put up a single short video of a demonstration of what he would describe as IP, or provide us with some examples of other people in videos demonstrating what he woud describe as IP and why this is so. If he puts up his own video then he can disallow comments on the uploaded site (youtube whatever) and let the forum guys say what they will, forum discussions fade into the past and the video itself will have no negative attachements on the source site (youtube) and can even be pulled down after a set time. At least then people will have a benchmark which will allow people unfamiliar with Dan's methods to begin a discussion on his terms, whether they agree with them or not.
Tom wrote:GrahamB wrote:Tom - not a private channel on YouTube - there's no such thing. What he's saying is post your videos on your own channel, but make them private and invite select people to view them.
What Graham said (from someone without a Youtube channel)
Return to Xingyiquan - Baguazhang - Taijiquan
Users browsing this forum: twocircles13 and 33 guests